SupremeCourt Judge Appointment Amid Controversy
The appointment of Justice Najafi has been made in accordance with the Constitution, but the controversy surrounding his nomination is likely to continue, with many in the legal fraternity calling for greater transparency and accountability in the appointment process. The Supreme Court's role in ensuring justice and upholding the rule of law will be closely scrutinized, particularly in light of the concerns raised regarding Justice Najafi's integrity and reputation.
President Asif Ali Zardari has approved the appointment of Lahore High Court Justice Ali Baqar Najafi as a judge of the Supreme Court, despite concerns raised by the legal fraternity regarding his integrity and reputation. The appointment was made under Articles 177(1) and 175A(8) of the Constitution, which provide for the president to appoint the chief justice and other judges after consultation with the chief justice.
The Judicial Commission of Pakistan had nominated Najafi for the position last week, citing his qualifications and experience. However, the commission had earlier considered Najafi's nomination for the LHC chief justice position in July 2024, but concluded that his nomination was not suitable due to alleged negative public perception regarding his integrity and reputation. The concerns regarding Najafi's integrity and reputation were highlighted in a letter seeking protocol privileges for his son at international airports in the UAE and the US, which was withdrawn by the LHC amid strong disapproval from the legal fraternity.
The oath-taking ceremony of Mr. Justice Ali Baqar Najafi was administered by Hon'ble Mr. Justice Yahya Afridi, Chief Justice of Pakistan, at the Supreme Court of Pakistan in Islamabad on April 16, 2025. The ceremony was attended by Hon'ble Judges of the Supreme Court, Attorney General for Pakistan, senior lawyers, and officers from the Federal Judicial Academy and Law & Justice Commission of Pakistan.
The appointment of Justice Ali Baqar Najafi as a judge of the Supreme Court has sparked debate within the legal community, with some questioning the decision to appoint him despite the concerns raised regarding his integrity and reputation. The development is likely to be closely watched in the coming days, as the Supreme Court plays a crucial role in shaping the country's judicial landscape.